Can you catch the legendary bluegill without Kieran?

Yes, you can catch the legendary bluegill without Kieran by finding it yourself using the legendary fish map from Jeremy Gill, but the mission with Kieran is the easiest way as he points it out and it's required to get the map in the first place; just make sure you have the Special Lake Lure and cast towards the ripples near a tree by the shore south of Clemens Point.
Takedown request View complete answer on reddead.fandom.com

Can you catch the legendary bluegill before Kieran?

You catch it independently or as part of the Stranger quest A Fisher of Fish. The Legendary Bluegill can be found south of Clemens Point off the shore of Flat Iron Lake. You will discover it if you accept Kieran's offer to go fishing during Chapter 3.
Takedown request View complete answer on ign.com

How do I catch the legendary bluegill?

To catch the Legendary Bluegill in Red Dead Redemption 2, head to the small inlet on the eastern shore of Flat Iron Lake, near Clemens Point, during Chapter 3's fishing mission with Kieran; use the Special Lake Lure, cast near the disturbances by a tree, and reel by pulling the rod up and down, opposing the fish's struggles, using your Hunter Vision to spot its distinct V-shape.
 
Takedown request View complete answer on youtube.com

Why can't I catch legendary bluegill?

It is rumored that this fish can only be attracted by using Special Lake Lures. Sightings of this fish have increased during rainy weather.
Takedown request View complete answer on reddead.fandom.com

What happens if you catch the legendary fish with Kieran?

If the player catches the Legendary Bluegill, Kieran heads back to camp. If the player doesn't, after some time, Kieran rides back to camp, finishing the mission.
Takedown request View complete answer on reddead.fandom.com

I Didn’t Know You Could Actually Catch Legendary Bluegill With Kieran - Red Dead Redemption 2

What's the rarest thing in RDR2?

The rarest items in RDR2 include unique weapons like Otis Miller's Revolver, the Legend of the East Outfit (requiring all challenges), specific Guarma items, the elusive White Arabian Horse, and missable collectibles such as certain Parakeets, gems in eagle nests, and the Ancient Arrowhead, often found through hidden encounters or specific side quests that many players skip. 
Takedown request View complete answer on youtube.com

What happens if you keep fishing with Dutch and Hosea?

Keeping fishing with Dutch and Hosea in Red Dead Redemption 2 results in a heartwarming, memorable bonding experience with valuable character development, reminiscing about the past, gaining Honor and a free fishing lure, and unlocking a camp rowboat, all enhancing your understanding of their friendship and the gang's early days, with the main thing you "miss" is a chance to buy the boat later if you skip it.
 
Takedown request View complete answer on reddit.com

What is the secret to catching bluegill?

The best way to catch bluegill involves a simple setup: a small hook (like a #6 Aberdeen) under a bobber with live bait (red worms, crickets) or scented soft plastics (Gulp!), targeting shallow areas near cover like lily pads or weed lines, especially in spring/summer when they're shallow and spawning. For deeper water or when they're finicky, use tiny jigs (1/32 oz) tipped with wax worms or plastics, often fished vertically or under a slip bobber. Focus on slow presentations, as bluegill often strike stationary or slowly moving food.
 
Takedown request View complete answer on reddit.com

Is there a trick to catching legendary fish in RDR2?

Use a full RDR2 legendary fish map for precise coordinates. Each location corresponds to either a lake, river, or swamp setting. Using the proper RDR2 special lure for that environment – lake, river, or swamp – is essential. If you use the wrong one, like a lake lure in a swamp, you won't attract the legendary fish.
Takedown request View complete answer on eneba.com

How to trigger a Fisher of Men RDR2?

To start "A Fisher of Men" in RDR2, progress the story into Chapter 2 until you get a prompt from Abigail to take Jack fishing; you'll need to complete other missions first, like some from the "Polite Society" or "Pouring Forth Oil" branches, then find Jack in camp and head to the river for a tutorial on how to fish and unlock the ability permanently.
 
Takedown request View complete answer on youtube.com

Do legendary fish respawn in RDR2?

No, once you catch a Legendary Fish in Red Dead Redemption 2, it's permanently gone from the world; they don't respawn like animals, but if you lose one after catching it (e.g., by dying or dropping it), it often goes to the Post Office or you might need to re-catch it at its original spot after a game day or two.
 
Takedown request View complete answer on youtube.com

How to catch massive bluegill?

To catch big bluegill, target deeper water and structure in spring/summer, use a small bobber with a piece of nightcrawler or cricket, or try small jigs/spinners, and focus on subtle presentations and fresh, active bait to avoid spooking wary, trophy-sized fish.
 
Takedown request View complete answer on reddit.com

What bait do I need for legendary fish RDR2?

To catch legendary fish in RDR2, you need the specific Special Lures: Lake, River, and Swamp, purchased from the bait shop in Lagras after starting Jeremy Gill's "Fisher of Fish" quest, and you must match the lure to the water type (lake, river, or swamp) where the fish is located. 
Takedown request View complete answer on reddit.com

Is there anyway to save Kieran RDR2?

Initially part of the O'Driscoll Boys, he's captured and forced to betray them by the Van der Linde gang. Despite his switch of allegiance, he's never fully trusted by his new group, and his old gang wants him dead. Consequently, the game does not provide an option to save Kieran Duffy.
Takedown request View complete answer on reddead.fandom.com

Can I catch a legendary fish twice?

Yes, you can catch some legendary fish more than once in Stardew Valley, but it's generally limited to specific circumstances like the Legend II during Mr. Qi's quest, or the original Legend via advanced methods like Challenge Bait or panning, while most other original legendaries (Crimsonfish, Angler, etc.) are typically one per save file. The standard rule for the first five legendaries is one catch per save, but the Extended Family quest offers repeat catches for their "II" versions, and the Legend itself has unique ways to be re-caught.
 
Takedown request View complete answer on reddit.com

What legendary fish is in Owanjila?

The legendary fish in Owanjila, Lake Owanjila, in Red Dead Redemption 2 is the Legendary Smallmouth Bass, a massive fish found in the waters near the dam, requiring a Special Lake Lure to catch as part of the "A Fisher of Fish" quest for Jeremy Gill.
 
Takedown request View complete answer on youtube.com

What is the biggest legendary fish in RDR2?

The biggest legendary fish in Red Dead Redemption 2 is the Legendary Channel Catfish, rumored to be huge (over 180 lbs) and located in the San Luis River, but it's widely considered uncatchable, existing more as a lore-based "troll" or cut content, while the largest catchable legendary is often cited as the Sockeye Salmon (around 54 lbs) or a massive Muskie.
 
Takedown request View complete answer on reddit.com

How to unlock special lake lure in RDR2?

To get the Special Lake Lure in RDR2, you must first start the "A Fisher of Fish" stranger mission by meeting Jeremy Gill at his cabin near Flatiron Lake, which unlocks the legendary fish map and the ability to buy the special lures from the Bait & Tackle shop in Lagras. After talking to Gill and getting the map, visit the Lagras bait shop (marked by a hook icon) and purchase the special lake lure to catch legendary lake fish.
 
Takedown request View complete answer on reddit.com

What is the 80/20 rule in fishing?

The 80/20 rule in fishing (Pareto Principle) suggests that 80% of the fish are caught by 20% of the anglers, using 20% of the lures, in 20% of the water. It means focusing on the "vital few" factors: identifying productive spots (structure, currents, tides), using a few effective lures/flies (like pheasant tails or trusted bass jigs), and understanding that most catches happen in specific conditions or areas, not everywhere. Applying it means simplifying your approach by identifying and maximizing these key inputs for better results.
 
Takedown request View complete answer on theminimalistfisherman.com

Why is bluegill so hard to catch?

Bluegills can seem hard to catch due to wrong conditions (murky water, bright sun), fishing pressure making them wary, being in the wrong spot (not near structure/weeds), using tackle too large for their small mouths, or simply being "shy biters" in clear water, but they're often easy when you match tiny hooks/jigs with the right depth and structure like weedlines or docks, especially in fall or during low light.
 
Takedown request View complete answer on wired2fish.com

What bait is good for bluegill rdr2?

You can catch Bluegil with Worm and Bread and Cricket as well, but cheese will maximize your chances. Lures will never catch bluegil.
Takedown request View complete answer on reddit.com

Who did Arthur love more, Hosea or Dutch?

"I love Dutch like a father, but in many ways, I love Hosea even more. He's kind and fair and like a human being." - entry in Arthur's journal.
Takedown request View complete answer on facebook.com

Is Dutch a bad person in rdr2?

Dutch Van Der Linde isn't a straightforward "bad guy"; he's a complex, tragic figure who starts as a charismatic leader but descends into paranoia, ruthlessness, and psychosis due to immense pressure, losses (like Hosea), and manipulation (primarily by Micah), eventually becoming a villain who betrays his own principles and family, showing he was always deeply flawed, or at least broke under the weight of a dying era. He's a cautionary tale of idealism corrupted by trauma and circumstance, ultimately becoming the antagonist to Arthur and John.
 
Takedown request View complete answer on reddit.com

Is it possible to save Hamish Sinclair?

Is it possible to save Hamish Sinclair in Red Dead Redemption 2? Hamish Sinclair, a former soldier and hunter in Red Dead Redemption 2, cannot be saved as per the game's storyline.
Takedown request View complete answer on reddead.fandom.com

Previous question
Is it possible to save both Duck and Shawn?
Next question
What 9 animals make up a dragon?