Should I give Gideon the potion?

The most practical choice is giving Seluvis' potion to Gideon, since this will advance Seluvis' quest with him none the wiser, while simultaneously sparing Nepheli Loux and the Dung Eater so that their questlines can continue as well.
Takedown request View complete answer on screenrant.com

What happens if I give Gideon the potion?

If you show the potion to Gideon, he will dispose of it himself, and order you to lie to Seluvis. If you choose this option, you'll miss out on a powerful summon. To give the Dung Eater the potion, you must progress through their questline past the point where you defeat them in Leyndell.
Takedown request View complete answer on polygon.com

Should I give the potion to Nepheli?

No, there are better options. Giving Nepheli the potion earns you the Dolores puppet Spirit summon, but locks you out of Nepehli's quest. Speak with Gideon instead – the grumpy man sitting at a desk outside the Table of Grace room – and he'll advise that you dispose of the potion, offering to dispose of it for you.
Takedown request View complete answer on vg247.com

What happens if I give Dung Eater the potion?

If you do give Seluvis' potion to Dung Eater, be sure to kill Dung Eater right after giving him the potion. He'll drop his armor. You must do it right away, if you reload the area he will be gone. Even if you kill him, Seluvis will still offer his puppet ashes to buy.
Takedown request View complete answer on gamefaqs.gamespot.com

Should I give the potion of forgetfulness?

Tonic of Forgetfulness Uses

You'll have the option to fulfill her request to kill her, give her the tonic, or refuse to give her the tonic. All three options will eventually reward you with the Daedicar's Woe Talisman, though the tonic will make her forget the details of her birth.
Takedown request View complete answer on ign.com

ELDEN RING - WHAT HAPPEN IF YOU GIVE GIDEON SELUVIS'S POTION DIALOGUE QUOTES

Should I give Seluvis potion to Gideon or Dung Eater?

The most practical choice is giving Seluvis' potion to Gideon, since this will advance Seluvis' quest with him none the wiser, while simultaneously sparing Nepheli Loux and the Dung Eater so that their questlines can continue as well.
Takedown request View complete answer on screenrant.com

What happens if I give the Tonic of Forgetfulness to Corhyn?

This action will unlock some bonus dialogue, but Corhyn will ultimately reject the tonic. However, this will slightly change the ending of his questline. Usually, once Leyndell transforms into the Capital of Ash, Corhyn can be found within the ruins, regretting his decision to follow Goldmask in Elden Ring.
Takedown request View complete answer on screenrant.com

Does killing Dung Eater give you his armor?

The Dung Eater actually has a full quest, and plays an important role in Elden Ring's 'Blessing of Despair' ending. However, to get his armor early, you will have to kill him as soon as you find him.
Takedown request View complete answer on gamerant.com

Should I leave Dung Eater alive?

Unlock the door and speak to the Dung Eater, commanding him to leave his cell. It can be tempting to kill him here, given what he informs you he's planning to do, but you must resist the urge if you're going to complete this quest.
Takedown request View complete answer on polygon.com

Should I curse the Dung Eater?

In order to progress his quest, you'll need Seedbed Curse otherwise, he will tell you to leave him alone. When you deliver the first Seedbed Curse to Dung Eater, he'll give you a Sewer-Gaol Key that can be used to unlock the sewer beneath Leyndell, Royal Capital.
Takedown request View complete answer on ign.com

Who killed Seluvis in Elden Ring?

You may attempt to give the Amber Draught to Ranni. Doing so will lock Ranni's questline, and it can only be resumed by seeking Absolution at the Church of Vows. Talking to her three times after trying to give her the draught will cause her to instantly kill you. Seluvis will now be dead.
Takedown request View complete answer on eldenring.fandom.com

Can you lie to Seluvis?

Return to Seluvis and tell him that you gave Nepheli the potion. Whether or not you chose to give it to her, or if you're simply lying to him, his quest will progress regardless.
Takedown request View complete answer on ign.com

What happens to Nepheli if she drinks the potion?

If you give the potion to Gideon and tell Seluvis you did as he asked, you'll still be able to buy Elden Ring sorceries from Seluvis. If you give the potion to Nepheli, she will turn into a doll and leave Roundtable Hold soon after, an eternal slave to Seluvis.
Takedown request View complete answer on pcgamer.com

Can you get black flame protection after killing Gideon?

Black Flame's Protection is obtained as a reward from Sir Gideon Ofnir in the Roundtable Hold after you have reached Miquella's Haligtree and told him of your findings. If you defeat him in Leyndell, Ashen Capital beforehand, you can buy it from the Twin Maiden Husks instead.
Takedown request View complete answer on ign.com

What does Gideon give you for beating Melania?

Gideon will now offer rewards in exchange for meeting certain requirements: Black Flame's Protection: activate a Site of Grace in Miquella's Haligtree. Lord's Divine Fortification: defeat Malenia, Blade of Miquella.
Takedown request View complete answer on eldenring.fandom.com

What level should you be to fight Gideon?

While Sir Gideon Ofnir is not a major boss, he is strong enough to kill you with a couple of hits from his powerful magic spells. But if you have defeated Maliketh, your character should already be at level 125 or higher, which is more than enough to face Gideon.
Takedown request View complete answer on polygon.com

Is Dung Eater the worst ending?

Elden Ring Dung Eater ending

To do this you have to follow the Dung Eater quest, but it's undoubtedly a bad ending, since you curse the world and all of its inhabitants.
Takedown request View complete answer on pcgamer.com

Where does Dung Eater go after you free him?

After your victory, the Dung Eater will return to the Roundtable Hold again and ask you to desecrate his body with the Seedbed Curse. His body can be found back in the sewers where you freed him from the dungeon. He is tied to a chair. The Dung Eater quest ends here.
Takedown request View complete answer on eurogamer.net

Does anything happen if the Dung Eater kills you?

Nothing happens but you get his armor if you complete his quest. He is one of the most disturbing things in this game. I was so glad to end him at the end of his questline. Nothing happens but you get his armor if you complete his quest.
Takedown request View complete answer on gamefaqs.gamespot.com

Does the Dung Eater ending give you a trophy?

However, while there is an achievement for becoming Elden Lord, which several endings involve, there is no specific achievement associated with Dung Eater's ending. In fact, nothing that Dung Eater requires the player to do, from interacting with him to collecting Seedbed Curses, will reward an achievement.
Takedown request View complete answer on screenrant.com

What weapon does Dung Eater drop?

The Sword of Milos is one of the greatsword Weapons in Elden Ring, dropped by the Dung Eater.
Takedown request View complete answer on ign.com

Should I let the Dung Eater out?

Talk to him to release him from his prison. Once released, Dung Eater becomes available as a cooperator for the fight against Mohg, the Omen. However, his summon sign will disappear if you advance his questline further or kill him.
Takedown request View complete answer on eldenring.wiki.fextralife.com

What do you get for killing Goldmask?

Loot his corpse to receive the Mending Rune of Perfect Order, which will unlock the option to complete the Age of Order ending.
Takedown request View complete answer on eldenring.fandom.com

Should you give rya tonic?

Should you give Rya the tonic in Elden Ring? Rya explains the truth of her birth and asks you to kill her. Don't do it, and refuse to give her the tonic.
Takedown request View complete answer on gamespot.com

Where is rya after killing Rykard?

If you choose to give Tonic of Forgetfulness, you can return to the manor and tell Tanith what you did for some extra dialogue. Once you go and defeat Rykard and return to the manor (when everyone's left) Rya will be at her original spot in the drawing room.
Takedown request View complete answer on pcgamer.com

Previous question
What elements scale with Arcane?
Next question
Did Diablo 4 sell well?