Should I give Nepheli the potion to Dung Eater?

The most practical choice is giving Seluvis' potion to Gideon, since this will advance Seluvis' quest with him none the wiser, while simultaneously sparing Nepheli Loux and the Dung Eater so that their questlines can continue as well.
Takedown request View complete answer on screenrant.com

Should I give the potion to Nepheli or Dung Eater?

Give him the potion instead, and he'll turn into Seluvis' puppet instead of Nepheli. Then, he will become available for purchase as a Spirit Ash from Seluvis, and the Dungeater Puppet is a damn good summon to use.
Takedown request View complete answer on vg247.com

What happens if you give the potion to a Dung Eater?

Speak to Dung Eater

Come to the outer moat." NOTE: Once you have found his corporeal form in the Subterranean Shunning Grounds, you now have the option to give him the potion from Selvius, which will net you the Dung Eater Puppet Spirit Ashes.
Takedown request View complete answer on ign.com

What happens if I give the potion to Nepheli?

If you give the potion to Nepheli, she will turn into a doll and leave Roundtable Hold soon after, an eternal slave to Seluvis. You can then buy her spirit summon from Seluvis later on but her quest will stop here.
Takedown request View complete answer on pcgamer.com

What to do after giving the Dung Eater Seluvis potion?

He will task the player with giving this potion to Nepheli Loux, but you should instead give it to Dung Eater in his cell. Afterward, purchase all of Seluvis' Sorceries and read his message within his secret Puppet Lab northwest of Ranni's Rise. Return to him and receive one of the Puppets.
Takedown request View complete answer on screenrant.com

Elden Ring - Killing Every Story NPC | What Happens ?

What happens if I give Dung Eater the Seedbed Curse?

Step 3: Speak to Dung Eater again

Our loathsome friend will finally open up to you when you return with a Seedbed Curse in hand. He'll give you the Sewer-Gaol Key and request that you free his corporeal form from the sewers beneath the Capital. Getting there is a bit of an ordeal, though.
Takedown request View complete answer on polygon.com

Is Dung Eater summon good?

The Dung Eater Puppet is one of Elden Ring's strongest and most versatile summons, which it better be, since you actually lock yourself out of an ending to get it. The summon does literally summon the Dung Eater, and he uses a bleed-inflicting sword up close and spirits of his own from afar.
Takedown request View complete answer on si.com

Is it worth giving Nepheli the potion?

If players opt to give Nepheli the potion, Seluvis' treachery is confirmed when Nepheli's Spirit Ashes can be purchased from him. This isn't recommended, since it will prematurely end Nepheli's questline, and hers aren't Spirit Ashes worth upgrading in Elden Ring.
Takedown request View complete answer on screenrant.com

Do you get anything for killing Nepheli?

7 Nepheli Loux

While killing her yields her Stormhawk Axes, there's arguably a fate even worse you can inflict upon her for your own benefit. Seluvis, up at Three Sisters, will ask you to give her a potion. Handing the potion over to Nepheli will result in her getting turned into one of the sorcerer's mindless puppets.
Takedown request View complete answer on thegamer.com

Who killed Seluvis in Elden Ring?

You may attempt to give the Amber Draught to Ranni. Doing so will lock Ranni's questline, and it can only be resumed by seeking Absolution at the Church of Vows. Talking to her three times after trying to give her the draught will cause her to instantly kill you. Seluvis will now be dead.
Takedown request View complete answer on eldenring.fandom.com

Should I do the Dung Eater ending?

Elden Ring Dung Eater ending

This is Dung Eater's version of the default ending, in which you use the Mending Rune of the Fell Curse on Fractured Marika. To do this you have to follow the Dung Eater quest, but it's undoubtedly a bad ending, since you curse the world and all of its inhabitants.
Takedown request View complete answer on pcgamer.com

Does killing Dung Eater give you his armor?

The Dung Eater actually has a full quest, and plays an important role in Elden Ring's 'Blessing of Despair' ending. However, to get his armor early, you will have to kill him as soon as you find him.
Takedown request View complete answer on gamerant.com

Can you do the dung eater quest after finishing the game?

Complete the Dung Eater's quest

After your victory, the Dung Eater will return to the Roundtable Hold again and ask you to desecrate his body with the Seedbed Curse. His body can be found back in the sewers where you freed him from the dungeon. He is tied to a chair.
Takedown request View complete answer on eurogamer.net

Can you summon Melina and Dung Eater?

(Optional) Alongside Melina, the Dung Eater can now be summoned to aid you against Morgott, the Omen King.
Takedown request View complete answer on eldenring.fandom.com

Should I progress the dung eater quest?

Completing this quest will get you a new armor set, and more importantly, an item required for one of the Elden Ring endings. You can meet the Dung Eater pretty early on in the game, though you won't be able to start his quest until you've picked up your first Seedbed Curse—usually when you reach the Royal Capital.
Takedown request View complete answer on pcgamer.com

How to get Dung Eater armor?

The Omen set can be found after killing the Dung Eater in the Subterranean Shunning-Grounds at the Leyndell Royal Capital. Killing the Dung Eater right after giving him Seluvis's Potion allows you to get both the Omen Set and the Dung Eater Puppet.
Takedown request View complete answer on eldenring.wiki.fextralife.com

Can you fail Nepheli's questline?

NOTE: Be sure to kill the Omenkiller field boss across the stone bridge in the Village of the Albinaurics while you're here; failure to do so may cause you to fail Nepheli's questline later on, as once you reach the Forge of the Giants, she disappears.
Takedown request View complete answer on ign.com

What if I killed Nepheli Loux?

Warrior Capable Of Easing One's Burden

If the Tarnished ignores her warning and chooses to attack, the Tarnished can slay Nepheli Loux. Doing so will grant the Tarnished with a Stormhawk Axe. This weapon is peanuts compared to what the Tarnished will get if she is kept alive.
Takedown request View complete answer on gamerant.com

What happens if I give Gideon the potion?

If you show the potion to Gideon, he will dispose of it himself, and order you to lie to Seluvis. If you choose this option, you'll miss out on a powerful summon. To give the Dung Eater the potion, you must progress through their questline past the point where you defeat them in Leyndell.
Takedown request View complete answer on polygon.com

What happens if I give Dung Eater the potion?

If you do give Seluvis' potion to Dung Eater, be sure to kill Dung Eater right after giving him the potion. He'll drop his armor. You must do it right away, if you reload the area he will be gone. Even if you kill him, Seluvis will still offer his puppet ashes to buy.
Takedown request View complete answer on gamefaqs.gamespot.com

What happens if you give the Stormhawk King to Nepheli?

Enter that door, climb the stairs, and pick up the Stormhawk King. Having found this key item, return to the Roundtable Hold and give it to Nepheli. This item will remind her of her past and the glory she felt as a warrior. It will revitalize her and allow you to complete this questline.
Takedown request View complete answer on thegamer.com

What to do after giving Nepheli the potion Elden Ring?

Giving her the potion effectively ends her questline early - before she is able to return to Stormveil Castle; however, it will give you the chance to earn an additional reward in the form of a summonable puppet granted to you by Seluvis. Return to Seluvis and tell him that you gave Nepheli the potion.
Takedown request View complete answer on ign.com

Is Dung Eater the most evil?

Of all the characters in the game, none are so thoroughly depraved and evil as Dung Eater. While he was truly alive, he saw a vision of a curse that he came to believe was his duty to bestow upon all living things.
Takedown request View complete answer on ign.com

Who is the tankiest summon in Elden Ring?

Lhutel the Headless is Elden Ring's best tank Spirit Summon, as she's equipped with heavy armor and a greatshield. She can also throw her spear for decent ranged damage and will constantly teleport around enemies, making it difficult for them to hit her.
Takedown request View complete answer on windowscentral.com

What is the strongest spirit summon in Elden Ring?

  1. 1 Mimic Tear. If there's one bit of consensus among Elden Ring's fans, it's that the Mimic Tear is the most powerful summon in the game.
  2. 2 Lhutel The Headless. ...
  3. 3 Black Knife Tiche. ...
  4. 4 Taylew the Golem Smith. ...
  5. 5 Ancient Dragon Florissax. ...
  6. 6 Demi-Human Swordsman Yosh. ...
  7. 7 Ancient Dragon Knight Kristoff. ...
  8. 8 Omenkiller Rollo. ...
Takedown request View complete answer on thegamer.com

Previous question
Can you turn off violence in RDR2?
Next question
What is the bad side of Fortnite?