Should I keep legendary fish or throw them back in RDR2?
You should keep legendary fish to mail to Jeremy Gill for rewards, but if you want more of the same legendary fish (for size or compendium), release it; releasing any legendary fish gives a significant honor boost, and you can catch the same legendary fish again if you let it go, allowing for bigger catches or more honor gains.What happens if you throw back a legendary fish in RDR2?
If you throw back a legendary fish in RDR2, it increases your honor and allows you to catch it again, potentially getting a larger one, but it does not respawn permanently for the quest until you've caught and mailed the first one to Jeremy Gill; it's best for getting multiple smaller legendary fish or boosting honor, not re-unlocking the quest for a new specimen.What should I do with legendary fish in RDR2?
With legendary fish in RDR2, you must first start the "A Fisher of Fish" quest by meeting Jeremy Gill at Flat Iron Lake, then catch the fish and mail them to him via any Post Office, storing them carefully on your horse; he sends rewards (money, items, unique rewards) after each delivery, and completing all deliveries unlocks the final Legendary Catfish challenge with Gill.Should I keep the legendary fish?
You should ** keep legendary fish in games like Stardew Valley for displaying in aquariums, using in fish ponds for income (with the 1.6 update), or for the challenge**, but you can also sell them as they are unique catches, and the achievement is for catching, not keeping them. It's a choice between early cash/energy (eat/sell) versus long-term decoration/income (pond/aquarium).What is the best thing to do with legendary fish?
Do not sell or smoke those legendary fish!!! You will make SO much more money putting them in fish ponds. i'm probably making a few hundred thousand gold a week just from selling aged roe from these ponds.Crossing Red Dead Redemption 2's entire map without taking a step
Are you supposed to throw fish back?
Unfortunately, people who practice “catch and release” cause no less harm to fish than do other anglers. Fish who are caught and then returned to the water suffer such severe physiological stress that they often die of shock, or their injuries may make them easy targets for predators.What happens if you keep fishing with Dutch and Hosea?
Keeping fishing with Dutch and Hosea in Red Dead Redemption 2 results in a heartwarming, memorable bonding experience with valuable character development, reminiscing about the past, gaining Honor and a free fishing lure, and unlocking a camp rowboat, all enhancing your understanding of their friendship and the gang's early days, with the main thing you "miss" is a chance to buy the boat later if you skip it.Can Arthur get all the legendary fish?
You can catch most legendary fish as Arthur, but the final few in New Austin and West Elizabeth are practically impossible without using glitches because of the "wanted dead or alive" status, invisible snipers, and bounty hunters; while you can glitch to catch them and mail them in, the quest only fully progresses and rewards you in the epilogue as John Marston, so the short answer is no, not legitimately.Can I catch a legendary fish twice?
Yes, you can catch some legendary fish more than once in Stardew Valley, but it's generally limited to specific circumstances like the Legend II during Mr. Qi's quest, or the original Legend via advanced methods like Challenge Bait or panning, while most other original legendaries (Crimsonfish, Angler, etc.) are typically one per save file. The standard rule for the first five legendaries is one catch per save, but the Extended Family quest offers repeat catches for their "II" versions, and the Legend itself has unique ways to be re-caught.Who do you give the legendary fish to in RDR2?
Once you've caught each fish, make sure you post them straight to Jeremy Gill or else it won't be marked off on the quest.What to do after catching all legendary fish in RDR2?
After catching a legendary fish in RDR2, you must store it on your horse (as it's too big for your satchel) and mail it to Jeremy Gill via any Post Office to progress the "Fisher of Fish" stranger mission and earn rewards, which is the only way to truly "complete" the catch. You'll get a map from Gill to find 13 legendary fish; deliver each one by mail for money, items, and progress towards a final encounter with Gill.Do the fish you throw back survive?
Controlled studies have shown that most fish released after hook-and-line capture, survive. Researchers working in Boca Grande Pass tagged 27 tarpon with sonic transmitters and found that 26 of these hook-and-line-caught fish survived. The one fish that died had been lifted from the water for a prerelease photograph.Can you catch the legendary fish with Kieran?
Yes, you absolutely can catch the Legendary Bluegill with Kieran during the Chapter 3 fishing mission in Red Dead Redemption 2, and it's a special moment where Kieran gets excited, but you need the right Special Lake Lure for it to work, not regular bait. The nude swimmer's hint leads you to the spot, and catching it triggers unique dialogue and a cool interaction with Kieran before he heads back to camp.Should I throw back legendary fish?
Returning a Legendary fish back to the water allows the player to catch it again. When kept, small and medium fish are stored in the satchel, while large fish need to be carried in hands or on horseback.Is Dutch a bad person in RDR2?
Dutch Van Der Linde isn't a straightforward "bad guy"; he's a complex, tragic figure who starts as a charismatic leader but descends into paranoia, ruthlessness, and psychosis due to immense pressure, losses (like Hosea), and manipulation (primarily by Micah), eventually becoming a villain who betrays his own principles and family, showing he was always deeply flawed, or at least broke under the weight of a dying era. He's a cautionary tale of idealism corrupted by trauma and circumstance, ultimately becoming the antagonist to Arthur and John.Can you actually catch the legendary channel catfish in RDR2?
No, you cannot actually catch the Legendary Channel Catfish in Red Dead Redemption 2; it's a famous in-game mystery and a "troll" from Rockstar, part of Jeremy Gill's quest, where he gets pulled in, but the fish itself remains uncatchable by players, despite appearing in the compendium and files. You complete the mission by accompanying Gill, taking a photo of his attempt, and then find his hat, with the fish never spawning naturally, although PC mods can reveal its unused model.What is the 80/20 rule in fishing?
The 80/20 rule in fishing (Pareto Principle) suggests that 80% of the fish are caught by 20% of the anglers, using 20% of the lures, in 20% of the water. It means focusing on the "vital few" factors: identifying productive spots (structure, currents, tides), using a few effective lures/flies (like pheasant tails or trusted bass jigs), and understanding that most catches happen in specific conditions or areas, not everywhere. Applying it means simplifying your approach by identifying and maximizing these key inputs for better results.What is the 10 minute rule for fish?
The 10-Minute Rule for cooking fish is a simple guideline: cook for 10 minutes per inch of thickness, measured at the thickest part, flipping once halfway through, for methods like baking, grilling, or pan-frying. This rule, also called the Canadian Cooking Method, helps avoid overcooking by focusing on thickness rather than just time, ensuring tender, flaky results.Why do people throw their fish back?
In the United States, catch and release was first introduced as a management tool in the state of Michigan in 1952 as an effort to reduce the cost of stocking hatchery-raised trout. Anglers fishing for fun rather than for food accepted the idea of releasing the fish while fishing in "no-kill" zones.How many endings does RDR2 have?
Red Dead Redemption 2 (RDR2) has four main endings for Arthur Morgan, determined by your final choices and honor level, with outcomes varying from Arthur dying peacefully or violently to a slightly different fate if he goes for the money instead of helping John. While some sources mention two main endings with honor variations, the consensus points to four distinct final scenes for Arthur.Can I catch legendary fish twice in RDR2?
In Red Dead Redemption 2, generally, you can only catch each legendary fish once per save file, as they disappear after being caught and mailed to Jeremy Gill, but you might be able to catch a specific one again if you lose it before mailing it or if it gets bugged out, allowing for a second attempt. Don't expect to catch them all multiple times for rewards; the game intends them to be unique catches for crafting, so if you want to retry a fight, save beforehand.
← Previous question
Is chapter 6 season 4 over?
Is chapter 6 season 4 over?
Next question →
What is the difference between steam and wet steam?
What is the difference between steam and wet steam?