Should you side with Madeline or he who was?
Ultimately, there are more material benefits to helping He Who Was than sticking with Madeline, even if that is a vile and wicked choice to make. But forgiving Madeline is the kinder choice overall. The correct choice is whatever makes the most sense for the player character in Baldur's Gate 3.Should I side with Madeline BG3?
Your best option is to side with He Who Was.He'll hand over Raven Gloves which let you summon a raven familiar. If you side with Madeline, He Who Was gets angry and you'll need to fight him but he doesn't drop anything useful.
Is he who was a good guy in BG3?
All in all, though, siding with He Who Was is likely the best option, unless you would just rather give Madeline the forgiveness she clearly deserves. For more on Baldur's Gate 3, check out where to find the Nightsong, and where to find the Blood of Lathander.What should I do with Madeline?
The “good” thing to do is absolve Madeline of her sins and let her rest in peace, which forces you to fight He Who Was. Torturing Madeline by making her stab herself is pretty clearly the “evil” option, for obvious reasons.What happens if you side with the devil in BG3?
If you accept the Baldur's Gate 3 Deal With the Devil proposal, you're told that you have to keep your promise (i.e. hand over the Crown of Karsus to Raphael later in the game). Going against this pact would mean losing your soul for eternity.He Who Was All Punishment choices - Baldur's Gate 3
Should I trust the devil in BG3?
You can trust Raphael in the short term, sure, but later in the game you'll want to decline his deal made in Act 3, where he offers you a specific weapon, and work to steal it from him instead. He's a devil by nature and by trade, instinctively cunning and controlling.Should I agree to the Devils Deal BG3?
Doing so will lead to one of the toughest optional boss fights in the game, but it'll also give players the most options when it comes to endgame choices. If players do want to enter the House of Hope, they should accept the deal.Can I trust he who was BG3?
Although inclined towards evil, helping He Who Was is the most beneficial choice in terms of rewards.Is Madeleine innocent in BG3?
Madeleine is guilty. 100%. She did the fantasy equivalent of denouncing people to the gestapo. She may have been doing it foolishly, she may not have thought clearly about the consequences, but her actions led to the death of people who trusted her.Should I fight he who was BG3?
Now you have a choice to make involving one of three Persuasion checks. Your best option is to side with He Who Was. He seems to take a great deal of pleasure in your decision, which he doesn't deny if you confront him about it. He'll hand over Raven Gloves which let you summon a raven familiar.Will the Emperor betray you in BG3?
First things first, freeing Orpheus will make the Emperor betray you and join the Netherbrain, since you're taking away his protection, which means you'll have to fight him during the final battle.Who is the most romanced character in Baldur's Gate 3?
Shadowheart Is the Most Popular Romance In the GameAccording to the stats Larian Studios released in December, Shadowheart is the most popular romance option with over 50% of romance routes going after her.
Should you side with the emperor in BG3?
To summarize, players should side with the Emperor if they don't want to become Mind Flayers, and they should free Orpheus if they don't mind risking having tentacles on them or their companions.Can you be evil in BG3?
1: Yes, going evil will have some companions leave you (specifically Karlach, Wyll, and Gale... though I think you can persuade Gale into staying.). In return you do get a couple evil companions. 2: While it is entirely possible to do an evil playthrough, doing so cuts out a massive portion of the game's content.Can you romance Gale BG3?
Gale does seem to be a bit of a love-hate character in terms of whether he comes across as charming, or an absolute creep, but either way, he is a romance option. Unlike a lot of the other characters, Gale's romance is a bit of a long haul, and you won't properly seal the deal until act two.Can you romance Astarion in Baldur's Gate 3?
How to romance Astarion in Baldur's Gate 3. To romance Astarion in Baldur's Gate 3, you first need to gain his approval ahead of the refugee celebration which occurs after completing the Save the Refugees side-quest.What should I do with Madeline BG3?
You have the option to make Madeline stab herself the same way her friends were forced to. You can also forgive her, easing her torment. In either of these paths, He Who Was will be furious and attack you, forcing you to kill him and ending the quest.Who is the bad guy in Baldur's Gate 3?
The Absolute, later known as the Netherbrain, is one of the three main antagonists (alongside Enver Gortash and Raphael) and final boss of the 2023 fantasy video game Baldur's Gate III.Should you tell Arabella her parents are dead?
Return to wherever you sent to Arabella stay and speak with her. To continue this questline, you must tell her the truth that her parents are deceased. She won't believe you and will run off. You must complete at least one long rest and return later to catch her speaking with either Withers or Alfira.Was Madeline guilty in BG3?
Fearing for her life, Madeline betrayed many of her friends and patrons to Netasha, who captured and killed them in horrific ways. Madeline will express grief and regret for her actions, believing herself beyond redemption or forgiveness.Can Astarion turn you?
He also becomes more romantically possessive, and, if the player character asks him nicely, will turn them into a vampire spawn, too. Upon another long rest, the ascended Astarion will give the player-controlled character the opportunity to turn into a vampire spawn by drinking a drop of his blood.Is Emperor evil in BG3?
He leans more toward evil than neutral. He's willing to kill his best friend and literally enslave the world using the Nether Brain. He even joins the Nether Brain if you don't side with him. He has no soul, as all illithids don't, and it's proven by his actions when you even slightly act against him.What is the best ending for BG3?
To get the good ending (or the standard story ending), you'll need to defeat the Netherbrain in the final battle of Act Three then command it to destroy itself, along with all the Ilithid Tadpoles.Can Raphael be killed in BG3?
He disappears and the party gains XP, which is always nice. However, since Raphael can only be killed for good if he's defeated in the Hells, he'll still come back later. It's good of him to let the attempt on his life slide, though, and still offer to help you out. The guy isn't too unreasonable.Can I trust Raphael in BG3?
Do not accept the deal with Raphael. Of course, if you are going for a more sinister character, then the deal may be enticing to you. However, for the most part, the deal is a bad one to take. Raphael is clearly up to no good, and his behavior is nothing if not suspicious.
← Previous question
What is the best Dragonborn armor?
What is the best Dragonborn armor?
Next question →
What Lycanroc forms are in scarlet and violet?
What Lycanroc forms are in scarlet and violet?