What happens if I throw a legendary fish back?
If you throw a legendary fish back in games like Red Dead Redemption 2, you can often catch it again to get a better quality one (if you want a bigger size) or to gain more honor, as releasing them gives a substantial honor boost; however, in other games like Stardew Valley, legendary fish are typically one-time catches per save file, and throwing them back won't let you re-catch them for that save.What happens if I throw back a legendary fish?
Returning a Legendary fish back to the water allows the player to catch it again.Should I keep legendary fish or throw them back in RDR2?
So if you catch a legendary bass or something then throw it back you can keep catching them until you get one large enough for your liking, since I've had a few 3 pound legendary that are kinda wimpy. So if you want some monster 10 lb fish then throw it back and don't keep it.Can you recatch legendary fish in RDR2?
No, in Red Dead Redemption 2, legendary fish are designed to be a one-time catch per save file; once caught and mailed to Jeremy Gill, they are gone forever from the world, but if you lose one (line breaks, die), it might respawn for another attempt after a few in-game days, say Reddit users.Does throwing fish back hurt them?
Most fish don't die when you throw them back if you do it correctly. Minimal handling, barbless hooks, and ``breath'' their gills before letting them loose.HOW TO GET A LEGENDARY FISH BACK IF YOU LOSE IT!! - Red Dead Redemption 2 Tips & Tricks
Do fish survive after being thrown back?
Yes, fish can survive catch and release, but survival isn't guaranteed and depends heavily on angler technique, gear, water conditions, and the fish's species; proper handling, using barbless or circle hooks, minimizing air exposure, and quick release significantly boost survival rates, while deep hooking or prolonged struggle can be fatal.What is the 80/20 rule in fishing?
The 80/20 rule in fishing (Pareto Principle) suggests that 80% of the fish are caught by 20% of the anglers, using 20% of the lures, in 20% of the water. It means focusing on the "vital few" factors: identifying productive spots (structure, currents, tides), using a few effective lures/flies (like pheasant tails or trusted bass jigs), and understanding that most catches happen in specific conditions or areas, not everywhere. Applying it means simplifying your approach by identifying and maximizing these key inputs for better results.Can I catch a legendary fish twice?
Yes, you can catch some legendary fish more than once in Stardew Valley, but it's generally limited to specific circumstances like the Legend II during Mr. Qi's quest, or the original Legend via advanced methods like Challenge Bait or panning, while most other original legendaries (Crimsonfish, Angler, etc.) are typically one per save file. The standard rule for the first five legendaries is one catch per save, but the Extended Family quest offers repeat catches for their "II" versions, and the Legend itself has unique ways to be re-caught.What happens if you keep fishing with Dutch and Hosea?
Keeping fishing with Dutch and Hosea in Red Dead Redemption 2 results in a heartwarming, memorable bonding experience with valuable character development, reminiscing about the past, gaining Honor and a free fishing lure, and unlocking a camp rowboat, all enhancing your understanding of their friendship and the gang's early days, with the main thing you "miss" is a chance to buy the boat later if you skip it.What is the biggest legendary fish in RDR2?
The biggest legendary fish in Red Dead Redemption 2 is the Legendary Channel Catfish, rumored to be huge (over 180 lbs) and located in the San Luis River, but it's widely considered uncatchable, existing more as a lore-based "troll" or cut content, while the largest catchable legendary is often cited as the Sockeye Salmon (around 54 lbs) or a massive Muskie.What's the best thing to do with legendary fish?
Do not sell or smoke those legendary fish!!! You will make SO much more money putting them in fish ponds. i'm probably making a few hundred thousand gold a week just from selling aged roe from these ponds. And adding an animal cracker is a game changer!Will legendary fish respawn in RDR2?
No, once you catch a Legendary Fish in Red Dead Redemption 2, it's permanently gone from the world; they don't respawn like animals, but if you lose one after catching it (e.g., by dying or dropping it), it often goes to the Post Office or you might need to re-catch it at its original spot after a game day or two.What's the hardest fish to catch in Red Dead Redemption 2?
There are several legendary creatures in Red Dead Redemption 2 for Arthur Morgan and John Marston to hunt down and catch, but the hardest one to tick off of the list may be the legendary bullhead catfish, and probably not for the reasons many would expect.How to get higher honor in Red Dead Redemption?
To increase your honor in Red Dead Redemption 2, perform good deeds like helping strangers, greeting people in towns (especially Saint Denis), donating to camp, and completing honorable choices in story missions; alternatively, fishing and releasing fish is a quick, repeatable method for steady gains, while catching outlaws non-lethally (disarming) also grants honor.Should I keep the legendary fish?
You should ** keep legendary fish in games like Stardew Valley for displaying in aquariums, using in fish ponds for income (with the 1.6 update), or for the challenge**, but you can also sell them as they are unique catches, and the achievement is for catching, not keeping them. It's a choice between early cash/energy (eat/sell) versus long-term decoration/income (pond/aquarium).Can you catch the legendary fish with Kieran?
Yes, you absolutely can catch the Legendary Bluegill with Kieran during the Chapter 3 fishing mission in Red Dead Redemption 2, and it's a special moment where Kieran gets excited, but you need the right Special Lake Lure for it to work, not regular bait. The nude swimmer's hint leads you to the spot, and catching it triggers unique dialogue and a cool interaction with Kieran before he heads back to camp.Is Dutch a bad person in RDR2?
Dutch Van Der Linde isn't a straightforward "bad guy"; he's a complex, tragic figure who starts as a charismatic leader but descends into paranoia, ruthlessness, and psychosis due to immense pressure, losses (like Hosea), and manipulation (primarily by Micah), eventually becoming a villain who betrays his own principles and family, showing he was always deeply flawed, or at least broke under the weight of a dying era. He's a cautionary tale of idealism corrupted by trauma and circumstance, ultimately becoming the antagonist to Arthur and John.Is there a trick to catching legendary fish in RDR2?
Use a full RDR2 legendary fish map for precise coordinates. Each location corresponds to either a lake, river, or swamp setting. Using the proper RDR2 special lure for that environment – lake, river, or swamp – is essential. If you use the wrong one, like a lake lure in a swamp, you won't attract the legendary fish.Who did Arthur love more, Hosea or Dutch?
"I love Dutch like a father, but in many ways, I love Hosea even more. He's kind and fair and like a human being." - entry in Arthur's journal.Is the legend needed for 100% completion?
They're required for perfection, yes.How many legendary fish can Arthur catch in RDR2?
You can catch most of the 13 Legendary Fish as Arthur Morgan, starting the quest by meeting Jeremy Gill, but you cannot complete the final part of the quest (meeting Gill at his cabin for the ultimate reward and 14th fish) because it's locked to the epilogue with John Marston due to game map limitations in New Austin and areas Arthur can't normally access. You'll get credit for the catches and journal entries as Arthur, but the final interaction requires John.What two colors do bass see best?
The answer appears to be a definite yes and an equally definite no. Bass apparently do see color. Their vision is strongest in the areas of medium-red to green.What is a ditch pickle?
A "ditch pickle" is slang for a largemouth bass, especially smaller ones caught in suburban, often muddy or less-than-pristine, drainage ditches or ponds, with "pickle" referencing its green color and "ditch" its habitat. It's a popular term among anglers for bass found in accessible, sometimes gritty, urban waterways, and also called "hammer handles," "slime rockets," or "green carp".What lure was banned from bass tournaments?
The Umbrella RigTwo of the largest organizations in the industry, the B.A.S.S. and the F.L.W. Outdoors tournaments, have banned the umbrella rig. They are illegal for a simple reason: they are so effective it's almost like cheating.
← Previous question
How fast to appear invisible?
How fast to appear invisible?
Next question →
How much did T1 Zeus get paid?
How much did T1 Zeus get paid?