What happens if I throw back a legendary fish?
If you throw back a legendary fish, it allows you to catch it again in some games, like Red Dead Redemption 2, letting you keep trying for a bigger one or to recover if you lost it, but in other games, such as Stardew Valley, it's a single-catch per save, and releasing it frees it for the quest or future pond use, not to be caught again, with outcomes varying by game design.What happens if you throw back legendary fish in RDR2?
If you throw back a legendary fish in RDR2, it increases your honor and allows you to catch it again, potentially getting a larger one, but it does not respawn permanently for the quest until you've caught and mailed the first one to Jeremy Gill; it's best for getting multiple smaller legendary fish or boosting honor, not re-unlocking the quest for a new specimen.Can you recatch legendary fish in RDR2?
No, in Red Dead Redemption 2, legendary fish are designed to be a one-time catch per save file; once caught and mailed to Jeremy Gill, they are gone forever from the world, but if you lose one (line breaks, die), it might respawn for another attempt after a few in-game days, say Reddit users.Can you recatch legendary fish in Stardew Valley?
It is one of the five Legendary Fish, so it can only be caught once per save file, or once per player in Multiplayer.What happens if you keep fishing with Dutch and Hosea?
Keeping fishing with Dutch and Hosea in Red Dead Redemption 2 results in a heartwarming, memorable bonding experience with valuable character development, reminiscing about the past, gaining Honor and a free fishing lure, and unlocking a camp rowboat, all enhancing your understanding of their friendship and the gang's early days, with the main thing you "miss" is a chance to buy the boat later if you skip it.Most Dishonorable Things You Can Do In RDR2 | 2
Will legendary fish respawn in RDR2?
No, once you catch a Legendary Fish in Red Dead Redemption 2, it's permanently gone from the world; they don't respawn like animals, but if you lose one after catching it (e.g., by dying or dropping it), it often goes to the Post Office or you might need to re-catch it at its original spot after a game day or two.Is Dutch a bad person in RDR2?
Dutch Van Der Linde isn't a straightforward "bad guy"; he's a complex, tragic figure who starts as a charismatic leader but descends into paranoia, ruthlessness, and psychosis due to immense pressure, losses (like Hosea), and manipulation (primarily by Micah), eventually becoming a villain who betrays his own principles and family, showing he was always deeply flawed, or at least broke under the weight of a dying era. He's a cautionary tale of idealism corrupted by trauma and circumstance, ultimately becoming the antagonist to Arthur and John.Can I catch a legendary fish twice?
Yes, you can catch some legendary fish more than once in Stardew Valley, but it's generally limited to specific circumstances like the Legend II during Mr. Qi's quest, or the original Legend via advanced methods like Challenge Bait or panning, while most other original legendaries (Crimsonfish, Angler, etc.) are typically one per save file. The standard rule for the first five legendaries is one catch per save, but the Extended Family quest offers repeat catches for their "II" versions, and the Legend itself has unique ways to be re-caught.How to get Owanjila legendary fish?
To catch the Legendary Smallmouth Bass in RDR2's Owanjila Lake, use a Special Lake Lure, find the spot near the dam/raised shore, cast towards the rocks or bubbles, and use the advanced reeling technique (pulling back the left stick periodically while clicking R3/right stick to stop line pull) to land this big fish for Jeremy Gill as part of "A Fisher of Fish" quest.Why can't I catch the legendary pike?
If your Legendary Pike isn't reeling in (likely in Red Dead Redemption 2), you need to match your actions to the fish's struggle: stop reeling and pull the left stick in the opposite direction when it fights, then reel fast with the right stick when it tires, using quick up-and-down flicks on the left stick for extra progress, and always use the specific Special Lure for that environment to even hook it.What is the biggest legendary fish in RDR2?
The biggest legendary fish in Red Dead Redemption 2 is the Legendary Channel Catfish, rumored to be huge (over 180 lbs) and located in the San Luis River, but it's widely considered uncatchable, existing more as a lore-based "troll" or cut content, while the largest catchable legendary is often cited as the Sockeye Salmon (around 54 lbs) or a massive Muskie.Can you catch the legendary fish with Kieran?
Yes, you absolutely can catch the Legendary Bluegill with Kieran during the Chapter 3 fishing mission in Red Dead Redemption 2, and it's a special moment where Kieran gets excited, but you need the right Special Lake Lure for it to work, not regular bait. The nude swimmer's hint leads you to the spot, and catching it triggers unique dialogue and a cool interaction with Kieran before he heads back to camp.Should I keep the legendary fish?
You should ** keep legendary fish in games like Stardew Valley for displaying in aquariums, using in fish ponds for income (with the 1.6 update), or for the challenge**, but you can also sell them as they are unique catches, and the achievement is for catching, not keeping them. It's a choice between early cash/energy (eat/sell) versus long-term decoration/income (pond/aquarium).Do the fish you throw back survive?
Controlled studies have shown that most fish released after hook-and-line capture, survive. Researchers working in Boca Grande Pass tagged 27 tarpon with sonic transmitters and found that 26 of these hook-and-line-caught fish survived. The one fish that died had been lifted from the water for a prerelease photograph.Is the legend needed for 100% completion?
They're required for perfection, yes.How many legendary fish can Arthur catch in RDR2?
You can catch most of the 13 Legendary Fish as Arthur Morgan, starting the quest by meeting Jeremy Gill, but you cannot complete the final part of the quest (meeting Gill at his cabin for the ultimate reward and 14th fish) because it's locked to the epilogue with John Marston due to game map limitations in New Austin and areas Arthur can't normally access. You'll get credit for the catches and journal entries as Arthur, but the final interaction requires John.What is the hardest fish to catch?
The hardest fish to catch varies by angler, but top contenders include the Tarpon (Silver King) for its explosive jumps & strong fight, Permit, notoriously picky eaters with bony mouths, Blue Marlin for sheer size & power, and the elusive Goliath Tigerfish, while freshwater challenges come from Arapaima (Amazon air-breathers) or bony-mouthed fish like Saratoga, making difficulty a mix of strength, smarts, and finicky feeding.What fish cost $1 million dollars?
Once used for cat food, the endangered fish is now one of the most prized delicacies in the world. Every year, on the first Saturday in January, Japan makes a grand statement to the global fishing community by putting an exorbitant price on the head of a single bluefin tuna.What happens if you marry a fisherman?
Being married to a fisherman can mean having “six honeymoons a year,” as one woman puts it. However, the short, intense periods of time together can also wreak havoc on the relationship.Which fish has 27000 taste buds?
Catfish have more taste buds than humans do in their mouths, with some species having over 27,000. These taste buds are spread across their entire bodies, including their skin, fins, and barbels (whiskers).Who is the real traitor in RDR2?
The main traitor who actively worked against the Van der Linde gang in Red Dead Redemption 2 was Micah Bell, who secretly snitched to the Pinkertons and manipulated Dutch, leading to the gang's downfall and the deaths of many members, though Dutch's own paranoia and eventual abandonment of the group also sealed their fate.Does Mary ever find out Arthur died?
Yes, Mary Linton learns of Arthur's death and visits his grave in the epilogue of Red Dead Redemption 2, shown mourning him in a cutscene during the credits, though how she found out and the exact location remains a mystery in the game, likely communicated by John or Abigail after Charles found the burial site.Did Dutch become a cannibal in RDR1?
No, there's no definitive proof that Dutch was a cannibal in RDR1, but it's a popular fan theory based on ambiguous evidence in his final hideout, like human-shaped bones and a blood-stained tub, suggesting extreme mental decline and potential Wendigo-like behavior, though these bones could also be decor or from animals, leaving it an open, unsettling possibility rather than a confirmed fact.
← Previous question
Are amiibos getting discontinued?
Are amiibos getting discontinued?
Next question →
What happens when a Tarrasque dies?
What happens when a Tarrasque dies?