What happens if you say no to helping Mary?
If you say no to helping Mary Linton in Red Dead Redemption 2, the questline "We Loved Once and True" permanently ends, locking you out of its completion and related achievements, with Mary expressing disappointment and ending things, though she later reveals her brother Jamie eventually left the cult anyway, implying Arthur made the right choice by not interfering.What happens if you choose not to help Mary?
If you don't help Mary Linton in Red Dead Redemption 2, her related missions, part of the "We Loved Once and True" questline, permanently end, meaning you won't receive her letters in Saint Denis, miss out on future interactions, and the chance to further develop their complex relationship with Arthur. Instead of her storyline progressing, you'll unlock a different mission ("An American Pastoral Scene"), effectively closing off that part of the game for that playthrough unless you reload a save.What happens to Jamie if you don't help him in RDR2?
If Arthur refuses to help Mary rescue Jamie, Mary will reveal that Jamie eventually left the cult and returned home, musing that Arthur was wise not to interfere.Is it better to be honorable or dishonorable in RDR2?
Neither honorable nor dishonorable is objectively "better" in RDR2; it's about playstyle, as each path offers unique benefits and impacts the story's tone, dialogue, and ending, with High Honor granting shop discounts, better loot, unique outfits, and a more redemptive narrative, while Low Honor gives better looting from bodies (like tonics/money) and allows for more chaotic, villainous roleplay but leads to a harsher story conclusion.Which is the hardest mission in RDR2?
The hardest mission in RDR2 is often debated, but "American Venom" is a top contender due to its intense, cover-less shootout with endless enemies and Micah, while other difficult missions include the challenging stealth/action of "Blood Feuds, Ancient and Modern", the frustrating "The Sheep and the Goats", and optional challenges like catching the White Arabian.I Created The Best Ending For Arthur Morgan in Red Dead Redemption 2 Alternate Ending
Is Sadie suicidal in RDR2?
During a job, Sadie confesses to John that she had developed a slight death wish over time.Is Tilly pregnant in RDR2?
Tilly will always be wearing worn black and white boots. By 1907, her appearance has changed very little. She is visibly pregnant and wears a dark blue striped dress, a white shirt, a red bow tie and a black belt.Is Low Honor Arthur evil?
At maximal Low Honour, Arthur can be played as a Near Pure Evil character, as he cares for his friends due to helping them, but can otherwise have no redeeming qualities whatsoever in killing countless innocents on optionally brutal ways, as well as being apathetic to the gangs' members deaths; notably indifferently ...What is the most honorable thing to do in RDR2?
Performing certain positive actions, like saving citizens from danger or aiding lawmen, will earn the player honor. Alternatively, taking negative actions, like attacking lawmen, aiding outlaws, stealing, and acting violently toward innocents, will result in the loss of honor.Should you help Mary Linton in RDR2?
You should help Mary in RDR2 if you want to see the full extent of her storyline and Arthur's complicated feelings, as refusing permanently closes that path; helping her continues the "We Loved Once and True" missions, reveals more of her family drama, and offers a poignant look at Arthur's past, even though she calls on him mostly for favors. Refusing just ends things with finality, but completing her quests adds depth, and you still get the valuable ring in the epilogue regardless of your choice.Is Henri Lemieux evil?
Mayor Henri Lemieux is a supporting character in Red Dead Redemption 2. He is the corrupt mayor of Saint Denis who hires the player (Arthur Morgan/John Marston) to deal with any threats to his power base and enrich himself.Can Arthur and Mary get together?
No, Arthur Morgan and Mary Linton cannot ultimately get together in Red Dead Redemption 2 due to their incompatible lifestyles—his life as an outlaw versus her desire for stability and family, despite their deep, lingering love and mutual longing. Their story is a tragic romance where both wish things were different, but neither is willing to abandon their core life path, leading Mary to make the painful decision to end things permanently for both their sakes.Is there a way to prevent Arthur from getting tuberculosis?
In Red Dead Redemption 2, Arthur Morgan always contracts tuberculosis (TB) as it's a core part of the story, usually from a cough during the Chapter 2 "Money Lending & Other Sins" mission with Thomas Downes, but players can delay it by avoiding that mission; however, to prevent it entirely, some players use exploits (like glitching to Guarma) or PC mods to essentially "save" a healthy Arthur, creating a non-canonical "good ending," though he's ultimately fated to get it in the main narrative.What happens if you help the man from Blackwater?
If you help the man from Blackwater, Jimmy Brooks, during the "Polite Society, Valentine Style" mission in Red Dead Redemption 2, you save him from falling off a cliff, gain significant Honor, and he gives you a pen as thanks for your mercy, though he's a bit surly about being saved. If you let him die, you lose Honor, and he falls to his death, silencing him. The poem found later at the Voodoo Shack changes depending on your choice, reflecting whether you saved or killed him.Is Micah afraid of Low Honor Arthur?
Yes, many players believe Micah fears or at least deeply respects a low-honor Arthur because he sees him as a ruthless equal, a true outlaw, which makes Arthur a rival he must defeat, whereas high-honor Arthur (redeemed) is just a nuisance to be left, but low-honor Arthur (still brutal) becomes someone Micah needs to prove he's better than, leading to a direct, spiteful confrontation and death at sunrise.How old is Sadie Adler?
Sadie Adler's exact age isn't stated in Red Dead Redemption 2, but she's generally estimated to be around 25 years old at the start of the main game (1899), making her one of the younger members of the Van der Linde gang, though some fan speculation places her in her late 20s or early 30s.Is Arthur or Dutch taller?
Yes, Dutch is generally depicted as being slightly taller than Arthur Morgan in Red Dead Redemption 2, though their exact heights are debated among fans, with Dutch often cited around 6'0" to 6'2" and Arthur around 5'10" to 6'1", making Dutch the taller, more commanding figure in the gang.Who is the true villain of RDR2?
The main antagonist in Red Dead Redemption 2 is Micah Bell, a sociopathic and manipulative member of the Van der Linde gang who betrays everyone for his own gain, ultimately leading to the gang's destruction and becoming a primary enemy for Arthur Morgan and John Marston. While other characters like Dutch van der Linde (devolving leader) and Andrew Milton (Pinkerton agent) also serve as antagonists, Micah is the most personal and direct threat to the protagonists, driving much of the story's conflict through his treachery and self-serving actions.Why is Merlin obsessed with Arthur?
Merlin's obsession with Arthur stems from a mix of destiny, deep friendship, love, and duty, where he's bound by prophecy to guide Arthur to become the great king who unites Albion and ushers in an age of peace, while also genuinely caring for Arthur as his best friend and someone he deeply trusts and admires. This intense bond means Merlin will do anything, even sacrifice himself, to protect Arthur, viewing him as central to bringing justice for magic users and fulfilling a world-changing purpose.Can I still play RDR2 after Arthur dies?
No, you can't freely play as Arthur after the main story ends and the epilogue begins; the game switches you to John Marston, but you can use glitches to spawn as Arthur for limited free roam by replaying missions or start a new game to play as Arthur from the beginning. The epilogue lets you finish up loose ends as John, but to truly play as Arthur again, you need to reload an earlier save from before Chapter 6 or use a mission replay glitch for temporary access, as he dies in the story.Does Timothee Chalamet play RDR2?
Chalamet made it no secret that he is a huge gamer and is a massive fan of Rockstar Games' open-world games namely the Red Dead Redemption prequel.Is Tilly autistic discovery?
While fans and viewers might interpret Tilly's behaviors as suggestive of autism, officially she is a fictional character designed to promote inclusivity. Her traits emphasize her strengths and individual personality rather than serve as a medical label.What is the age gap between Arthur and John?
Arthur Morgan is about 10 years older than John Marston, with Arthur being around 36 and John around 26 during the main events of Red Dead Redemption 2 in 1899, making Arthur roughly a decade his senior.
← Previous question
How do I split an item in Poe?
How do I split an item in Poe?
Next question →
Can you light fire in an igloo?
Can you light fire in an igloo?