Why did Dutch shoot the girl in Blackwater?

Arthur mentions that Dutch shot a woman in Blackwater. This was likely Dutch's attempt to create some distance between the gang and the Pinkertons. From there, several gang members slowed themselves down and, instead of helping them, Dutch left them behind so that he could escape.
Takedown request View complete answer on thegamer.com

Why did Dutch kill the girl on the ferry?

He mentions that Micah Bell encouraged Dutch to kill her, and that Dutch later justified it by saying that it was what they had to do to survive.
Takedown request View complete answer on reddead.fandom.com

What did Dutch do to the girl on the boat?

Heidi McCourt was a bystander on the ferry during the Van der Linde gang's attempted robbery and, upon encouragement from Micah Bell, Dutch apparently gunned her down.
Takedown request View complete answer on thegamer.com

Why did Dutch kill the girl in Blackwater reddit?

The most straightforward event seems to be that Heidi was a random hostage that Dutch picked up, and just shot after the gang was fully surrounded by law enforcement and Dutch couldn't find a way out. A similar situation to how he treated the female hostage in RDR1.
Takedown request View complete answer on reddit.com

Why did Dutch kill Micah?

Dutch shoots Micah because he owes that to Arthur, in a way Dutch gains his redemption by shooting the man responsible for the downfall of his gang and the death of his surrogate son.
Takedown request View complete answer on quora.com

THAT'S why Dutch murdered the girl on the boat.. - Rdr2

Why does Micah laugh when Dutch shoots him?

Micah laughing after being mortally wounded by Dutch, despite obviously being in extreme pain, and then giving a nonchalant shrug moments after he's finished off by John could be evidence that Micah is so vindictive, he doesn't care about his own death as long as he knows John will eventually pay for his murder, since ...
Takedown request View complete answer on villains.fandom.com

Why didn t Dutch let Arthur kill Micah?

Dutch knows Micah betrayed him, which is why Dutch turns his back on Micah during the good ending of Red Dead Redemption 2 after Arthur Morgan dies. Now, years later, Dutch Van Der Linde arrives at Micah's wanting to kill him. It's why Dutch tells John Marston he's there for the same reason John is.
Takedown request View complete answer on screenrant.com

Why did Dutch go evil?

However, the Pinkertons' pursuit, the death of his companions (especially Hosea), and the advancement of society made Dutch begin to become crazy and he became more and more ruthless, egotistical, narcissistic, and vindictive.
Takedown request View complete answer on villains.fandom.com

Is Dutch Van der Linde evil?

6 Dutch Van Der Linde

While he is initially seen as a father figure to the gang, his descent into madness is fuelled by the death of characters like Hosea. Over time, he falls for Micah's manipulation and leads the gang to ruin, becoming a target in Red Dead Redemption for Marston to hunt down and kill.
Takedown request View complete answer on gamerant.com

How much money did Dutch steal in Blackwater?

The Blackwater Massacre, as it comes to be referred to, led to the loss of $150,000 from the ferry that the gang targeted. Due to the arrival of Pinkertons and police to the area, the heist went wrong swiftly, causing Davey Callander and Jenny Kirk to be killed.
Takedown request View complete answer on gamingbible.com

What mental illness does Dutch have in RDR2?

All in all, it's clear that Dutch is suffering from a personality disorder, and he's a textbook narcissist. Narcissism is defined by dramatic and exaggerated traits, emotional intensity, as well as acting erratically and unpredictable. Dutch's whole schtick is dramatic.
Takedown request View complete answer on thegamer.com

Why did Molly betray Dutch?

Why Did Molly Lie In Red Dead Redemption 2? Things take a turn for the worse – for Molly, that is – when Uncle finds her drunk in Saint Denis and brings her back to the camp. Molly is clearly furious with Dutch, and she begins drunkenly berating him, talking about how he's ignored her and she only ever loved him.
Takedown request View complete answer on screenrant.com

Why did Dutch betray Arthur?

Dutch Would Have Eventually Seen Arthur As A Threat In RDR2

He repeatedly tells Arthur and others that they have to stick to his plan in order to survive, even as circumstances continue to worsen around them. Dutch wants to be the one in charge no matter what, and he wants his orders to be the law of the gang.
Takedown request View complete answer on screenrant.com

Why did John kill Dutch?

In 1911, Marston is sent by government agents to kill his former brothers-in-arms, including Dutch himself. After dealing with Bill and Javier, John is sent to bring end to Dutch's crimes.
Takedown request View complete answer on rockstargames.fandom.com

Why did Dutch go crazy?

During the mission Urban Pleasures when riding the trolley they crash into a wagon and Dutch might have damaged his head when crashing onto the trolley ceiling he did have some sort of blood or bruise on his head so it might make sense but that's just a theory.
Takedown request View complete answer on reddead.fandom.com

When did Dutch start going crazy?

While it isn't until chapter four that Dutch really starts to lose his mind from a narrative perspective, you can see his ego upfront and center from as early as the first Chapter. Even the first mission is quite frankly enough to telegraph that Dutch's gang is run entirely by his ego.
Takedown request View complete answer on thegamer.com

Is Micah alive in RDR1?

Before Micah can be killed, Dutch emerges from a cabin, guns drawn. Micah manages to overpower Sadie, holding her hostage, and a Mexican stand-off ensues between John, Micah and Dutch. Dutch initially appears to be on Micah's side, but eventually shoots Micah in the chest, mortally wounding him.
Takedown request View complete answer on reddeadfanon.fandom.com

Who is the smartest Van der Linde member?

Without the wisdom and guidance of Hosea's logic, it's safe to say that the Van der Linde gang would have fallen apart far quicker than it did. Hosea is the brains of the operation and has swindled himself into fat pockets of cash on multiple occasions.
Takedown request View complete answer on gamerant.com

Who killed Arthur Morgan?

The vengeful Micah soon ambushes him, and Dutch intervenes. Arthur convinces Dutch to abandon Micah and leave. If the player has high honor, Arthur succumbs to his injuries and disease, dying peacefully while watching the sunrise; with low honor, Micah executes him.
Takedown request View complete answer on en.wikipedia.org

Did Dutch's head injury make him crazy?

In yet another job that goes south early into the game, the gang's fearless leader takes a major blow to the noggin and becomes dazed for the rest of the mission. The theory posits that Dutch was left with a brain injury as a result of the blow, and that this ultimately leads to his downward spiral.
Takedown request View complete answer on gamingbible.com

Who killed John Marston?

With his old gang dead, John and his family are returned to their ranch. He spends some time working on the ranch, but it is soon attacked by a detachment of U.S. soldiers, and Uncle is killed. John defends his family, but is shot and killed by the soldiers and Ross. His body is buried on a hillside at the ranch.
Takedown request View complete answer on en.wikipedia.org

Does Dutch regret his actions?

On several occasions in the games, albeit subtly, Dutch expresses genuine remorse for his actions: After the murder of Leviticus Cornwall, when Arthur gets mad at Dutch about it, Dutch tells Arthur that he has done many bad deeds that he regrets doing, but the murder of Cornwall is not one of them.
Takedown request View complete answer on inconsistently-heinous.fandom.com

Why did Dutch favor Micah?

Because Micah told Dutch what he wanted to hear. It's really that simple. After Hosea's death, the botched Saint Denis heist, and Arthur seeing Dutch's increasing ruthlessness. Arthur began to wonder if Dutch was the man who he thought he was, and he began to doubt in Dutch and his supposed ideals.
Takedown request View complete answer on quora.com

What will RDR3 be about?

Speculation suggests that RDR3 would be a prequel to maintain the game's Wild West atmosphere and themes. Possible protagonists for RDR3 include Jack Marston, Dutch Van der Linde, Mac Callander, and Charles, each offering unique story opportunities.
Takedown request View complete answer on imdb.com

Why did Micah shoot Grimshaw?

Adding to the confusion is John's reappearance as he accuses Dutch of abandoning him. Grimshaw takes Arthur and John's side, but Micah shoots her in the stomach when she is distracted. She slowly and painfully bleeds out and the rest of the gang turn on Arthur and John.
Takedown request View complete answer on villains.fandom.com

Previous question
Is Switch v2 hackable reddit?
Next question
Am I too old to play Nintendo?