Why is it impossible to catch legendary fish in RDR2?
It's not impossible to catch legendary fish in RDR2, but they're tough because they're stronger, requiring specific techniques like using the correct special lures, balancing reeling (left stick) and resisting (R3) to manage line tension, and understanding that legendary fish often appear at specific times (dawn/dusk/rain) in precise locations indicated by the map's crown symbol. Many players struggle with the timing, the tedious reeling, or using the wrong gear, leading to broken lines or lost fish, but the challenge is part of the game's design.Why can't I catch legendary fish in RDR2?
Use a full RDR2 legendary fish map for precise coordinates. Each location corresponds to either a lake, river, or swamp setting. Using the proper RDR2 special lure for that environment – lake, river, or swamp – is essential. If you use the wrong one, like a lake lure in a swamp, you won't attract the legendary fish.Why can't I catch the crimsonfish?
The crimson fish only spawns on the far right dock so if you fish on either of the other two you won't encounter it.Can you actually catch the legendary channel catfish in RDR2?
No, you cannot actually catch the Legendary Channel Catfish in Red Dead Redemption 2; it's a famous in-game mystery and a "troll" from Rockstar, part of Jeremy Gill's quest, where he gets pulled in, but the fish itself remains uncatchable by players, despite appearing in the compendium and files. You complete the mission by accompanying Gill, taking a photo of his attempt, and then find his hat, with the fish never spawning naturally, although PC mods can reveal its unused model.What's the hardest fish to catch in Red Dead Redemption 2?
There are several legendary creatures in Red Dead Redemption 2 for Arthur Morgan and John Marston to hunt down and catch, but the hardest one to tick off of the list may be the legendary bullhead catfish, and probably not for the reasons many would expect.HERE'S WHY You CAN'T Catch That LEGENDARY FISH!! (FIX) - Red Dead Redemption 2
What fish cost $1 million dollars?
Once used for cat food, the endangered fish is now one of the most prized delicacies in the world. Every year, on the first Saturday in January, Japan makes a grand statement to the global fishing community by putting an exorbitant price on the head of a single bluefin tuna.How hard is it to catch legendary fish in RDR2?
Fishing for legendary fish can take much more time than normal, and it's important to stay patient. If you've spent five minutes in one area and nothing has happened, draw the line back and move to a different spot. As long as it's within the correct area, you'll be fine.Can you catch the legendary fish with Hamish?
When you've reached the fishing spot, Hamish gives you a special lake lure for legendary fish (if you haven't already acquired it). Although the fish in this mission is called a "legendary", it is not part of the checklist or mission progress for A Fisher of Fish.What bait to use to catch legendary catfish in RDR2?
To catch Legendary Catfish in RDR2 (specifically the Bullhead near Sisika), you need the Special River Lure, bought at the bait shop in Lagras after meeting Jeremy Gill; you'll cast this near the penitentiary, rowing out to the small island, and the fish is often active in overcast/rainy weather, requiring patience and strong reeling.What is the reward for catching the catfish?
The initiative, run by the Environmental Justice Journalism Initiative (EJJI), rewards local anglers with $30 for every invasive fish head they turn in—including blue catfish and flathead catfish.What is the 80/20 rule in fishing?
The 80/20 rule in fishing (Pareto Principle) suggests that 80% of the fish are caught by 20% of the anglers, using 20% of the lures, in 20% of the water. It means focusing on the "vital few" factors: identifying productive spots (structure, currents, tides), using a few effective lures/flies (like pheasant tails or trusted bass jigs), and understanding that most catches happen in specific conditions or areas, not everywhere. Applying it means simplifying your approach by identifying and maximizing these key inputs for better results.Is fishing based on skill or luck?
Luck has and always will be a part of fishing. However, an angler's skill creates situations where luck has a better chance of happening. In fishing, as with many other things in life, skill is what lets luck happen.How do I avoid breaking my line while fishing?
Make sure when you're pairing your line, lure and rod, that you don't overpower the line. Be sure to tie, lubricate and properly cinch down your knot when tying it. And don't forget to check your drag often to make sure it's not too tight or too loose.How to trigger a Fisher of Men RDR2?
To start "A Fisher of Men" in RDR2, progress the story into Chapter 2 until you get a prompt from Abigail to take Jack fishing; you'll need to complete other missions first, like some from the "Polite Society" or "Pouring Forth Oil" branches, then find Jack in camp and head to the river for a tutorial on how to fish and unlock the ability permanently.Can you catch the 200 lb catfish in RDR2?
No, you cannot naturally catch the rumored 200 lb Legendary Channel Catfish in Red Dead Redemption 2; it's an infamous piece of cut content, a "fish tale" meant to be uncatchable, even though it appears in the Compendium and has game files, with its quest ending in the mysterious disappearance of fisherman Jeremy Gill. While some players have used PC mods to spawn its model (which glitches and is massive), it's not a legitimate part of the game's intended experience, leaving it as a legendary mystery.What is secret 7 catfish bait?
Team Catfish Secret 7 Dip Bait (16oz) Secret 7 catches channel cats and blue cats alike. It has a silky smooth texture with sticky blend of fish attractants that drive catfish wild. SECRET-7 dip bait is great in ponds, lakes, rivers, or streams.What happens if you keep fishing with Dutch and Hosea?
Keeping fishing with Dutch and Hosea in Red Dead Redemption 2 results in a heartwarming, memorable bonding experience with valuable character development, reminiscing about the past, gaining Honor and a free fishing lure, and unlocking a camp rowboat, all enhancing your understanding of their friendship and the gang's early days, with the main thing you "miss" is a chance to buy the boat later if you skip it.What is the rarest horse breed in RDR2?
The rarest horse in RDR2 is subjective, but many players point to the Few-Spotted Appaloosa, the Splashed White American Paint, or one-time mission horses like Buell (American Standardbred) or Hosea's Raven Black Shire, as these often have unique conditions, limited spawns, or are tied to specific, missable encounters, making them harder to find than the popular but common-to-find White Arabian.Can I keep Buell forever?
The player can choose to mount Buell and keep him for themselves, leave him behind, or sell him at a horse fence or stable. Afterwards, Buell can become a permanent horse for the player.What is the hardest fish to catch in Red Dead Redemption 2?
The hardest fish to catch in RDR2 often depends on player preference, but the Legendary Bullhead Catfish (annoying location) and Legendary Sockeye Salmon (strong line-breaker) are frequent mentions, alongside the tricky, awkward spot for the Legendary Muskie, while the mysterious Legendary Channel Catfish remains uncatchable and a game legend. Players find success by mastering the reeling technique (tapping/pulling left stick) and using the correct special lure.Why can't I catch the crimsonfish?
The special requirements necessary to hook a Crimsonfish are: Fishing level 5, either naturally or using Fishing Buffs. The player must be standing at the far east end of the beach, which can be reached after repairing the small bridge for 300 wood or purchasing the second community upgrade.What happens if you lose a legendary fish?
If you lose a legendary fish (like in RDR2 or Stardew Valley), it usually respawns after a few in-game days back in its original spot, or sometimes goes to a post office for you to retrieve and mail, but the key is patience and returning to the original fishing location to try again, as you can often re-catch it.
← Previous question
Are Rathalos extinct in Monster Hunter Stories 3?
Are Rathalos extinct in Monster Hunter Stories 3?
Next question →
Is Return the best ending in Sekiro?
Is Return the best ending in Sekiro?