Can legendary planeswalkers be your Commander?
No, standard legendary planeswalkers cannot be your commander in Magic: The Gathering's Commander format; only Legendary Creatures or specific Planeswalkers with the text "This card can be your commander" are allowed, but you can always use Rule Zero with your playgroup to allow any Planeswalker as a casual commander. While all Planeswalkers are Legendary in rules text now, the core Commander rule requires a Legendary Creature unless the card itself grants permission.Can any legendary be your Commander?
Players choose a legendary creature to be their commander. However, several abilities have the potential to expand the options for what may be chosen as a commander. Some legendary non-creature cards (usually planeswalkers) have an ability allowing them to be chosen as a commander.Can any Planeswalker be a Commander in 2025?
The rule for Commander is that any (not-banned) Legendary Creature can be your commander. Planeswalkers are not Legendary Creatures.Why can't all planeswalkers be commanders?
Planeswalkers can't be default commanders in Magic: The Gathering's Commander format because the format was established before Planeswalkers existed and requires commanders to be Legendary Creatures, which most Planeswalkers aren't; plus, allowing them could break balance with powerful combos (like with The Chain Veil or Doubling Season) and slow games, though some specific Planeswalkers with special text can be commanders, or you can house-rule it for fun.How many legendary planeswalkers can you have in Commander?
In all formats except Commander, you can have as many planeswalkers as you like. In Commander, you could have up to 99, as that format is restricted to 100 cards exactly, including your commander.Can Planeswalkers be Commanders? ┃ Magic the Gathering ┃ Magic for Beginners
Can I use a legendary planeswalker as my Commander?
No, normally legendary planeswalkers can't be commanders in Magic: The Gathering Commander; your commander must be a legendary creature, but some planeswalkers have text saying "This card can be your commander" or are legendary creatures that transform into planeswalkers (like Grist or Valki), making them exceptions. For regular planeswalkers without that specific text, you need to get "Rule 0" approval from your playgroup to use them as commanders.Is 40 lands too much Commander?
40 lands in a Commander deck isn't inherently "too much," but it's on the higher end for typical decks; it's often perfect for high-mana curve decks, <<<>>landfall strategies, or decks with little card draw, but fewer lands (35-38) might be better if you have lots of ramp and draw spells. It depends heavily on your deck's strategy, average mana cost (CMC), and inclusion of mana rocks/ramp, with many players finding 36-40 a solid baseline for casual play.How do legendary planeswalkers work in MTG?
Planeswalkers usually have three abilities: one ability that adds loyalty counters as a cost for a small benefit, one that removes a small number of counters as a cost for a larger effect, and one that removes a large number of loyalty counters for a big effect.Why can Grist be a Commander?
Well, Grist is a 1/1 Insect creature when it isn't on the battlefield, therefore making it a creature in the command zone.Are planeswalkers worth it in Commander?
Be aware that Planeswalkers are fairly weak in Commander. It's safe to assume that all three opponents will attack your Planeswalker if given the chance, because most Planeswalkers will just run away with the game on their own if not dealt with early.Can legendary enchantments be commanders?
Yes, legendary enchantments can be commanders, specifically Legendary Enchantment Creatures (like Gods or new Saga creatures) and Legendary Enchantments with specific "Can be your Commander" text, or Legendary Enchantments that become Creatures, but generally, a pure Enchantment (not also a Creature) needs special rules or the Background partner mechanic to work as a commander. The core rule is that it must be a legendary permanent that functions as a creature in the command zone or has explicit text allowing it, such as the Backgrounds or some Planeswalkers/Artifacts.What is a good ratio for a Commander deck?
A good starting Commander deck ratio is around 36-38 lands, 10-12 ramp, 10-12 card draw, and 10-12 removal/interaction, with the rest of the ~30 slots dedicated to your deck's theme, creatures, and finishers, but this varies heavily by strategy (e.g., creature-heavy vs. spell-focused) and your Commander's abilities. The core idea is to have enough lands for consistency, enough ramp to cast spells, and enough draw/removal to keep pace, then fill the rest with synergistic cards.Can planeswalkers be commanders in Tiny Leaders?
In Brass Tiny Leaders, you may play any (non-banned) Planeswalker as your commander. Not only Aminatou, the Fateshifter but any Planeswalker.Is 40 creatures too many in Commander?
You'll want as many of the chosen creature types as possible if you decide to run a typal deck. Depending on the creature type, you could run at least 30 to 40 or more creatures in the build. Of course, this also depends on the utility of each creature you include.How do you bypass the legend rule?
There are also two indirect ways to bypass the legend rule: creating a copy of a legendary creature under a different name (Lazav, Dimir Mastermind) and creating a copy of a legendary creature that isn't legendary (Helm of the Host).What is the point of playing EDH?
The main consensus is that EDH is a fun multiplayer past time, where you can test your jank. You do not play to win, you play to see how your deck interacts with itself and with the others most of the time.Is Grist a legal oathbreaker?
they are a legal oathbreaker. They are a planeswalker, that happens to also sometimes be a creature.Is Seven Dwarves legal in Commander?
The Rule of SevenSeven Dwarves is different, though: you can have no more than seven copies of the card in your deck. When building a 60-card deck, having seven copies of Seven Dwarves means you have decent odds at getting two or possibly even three of them on the battlefield, which makes each of them bigger.
Can you use legendary planeswalkers as commanders?
No, you can't use any legendary planeswalker as a commander in Magic: The Gathering's Commander format; only those with specific text saying "this card can be your commander" are allowed, otherwise, you must use a legendary creature, though groups can agree to "Rule Zero" to allow others, or use the Brawl format where any planeswalker works.What is the most powerful planeswalker in MTG?
The strongest Magic: The Gathering planeswalkers often cited for game-breaking power and impact include Oko, Thief of Crowns (banned in many formats for being too dominant), Jace, the Mind Sculptor (historically dominant card-drawing/control), Wrenn and Six (recurrent land utility), Liliana of the Veil (sacrifice/discard engine), and disruptive Teferis like Teferi, Time Raveler, while lore-wise characters like Urza and Nicol Bolas are considered near-godlike, with power levels shifting based on format (Commander, Modern, etc.) and era.Who are the original 5 planeswalkers?
The original five Magic: The Gathering Planeswalkers, known as the "Lorwyn Five," introduced in the Lorwyn set (2007) are Jace Beleren, Chandra Nalaar, Liliana Vess, Ajani Goldmane, and Garruk Wildspeaker; they were the first monocolored Planeswalkers printed as cards, representing each color (Blue, Red, Black, White, Green) and establishing the iconic template for Planeswalker cards that followed.What is the ideal mana curve?
The ideal is curving out perfectly with a one-drop on turn one, a two-drop on turn two, and so on (which amounts to spending 1+2+3+4+5=15 mana over the course of the first five turns). Such a perfect curve would typically beat an opponent who only manages to cast, say, 10 mana worth of cards in the first five turns.What is the 32 deck challenge?
For those who are not aware, the 32 deck challenge is to build one deck for every possible colour combination, from colourless to 5C. So the purpose of this thread is to see how far through you are, what you've brainstormed, or just to see what others are building.
← Previous question
What happens if you sleep after killing Toriel?
What happens if you sleep after killing Toriel?
Next question →
Is Twilight Princess 4:3 or 16:9?
Is Twilight Princess 4:3 or 16:9?