Do copies trigger ETB effects in MTG?
Yes, copies of creatures in Magic: The Gathering almost always trigger "Enter the Battlefield" (ETB) effects because the game recognizes them as a new permanent entering the battlefield, adding their abilities (including copied ETB triggers) to the stack, even for legendary creatures where the Legend Rule will force one to be sacrificed immediately after.Does copying a creature trigger ETB effects?
Yes, that copy enters the battlefield, and all applicable ETB (or, starting with Bloomburrow, E) triggers will go on the stack.Do clones get ETB effects?
Yes. Clone effects are replacement effects that change how your clone enters the battlefield. If you copy something with an ETB trigger, the game "sees" a copy of that creature entering the battlefield and the ETB trigger goes on the stack.Do legendary copies still trigger ETB?
The effect will still trigger, but won't go on the stack until SBAs are checked. The legend rule will apply, and you put ETBs on the stack, but by the time the triggered abilities are resolving, you would've applied the legend rule long before.Does copying count as entering the battlefield?
Yes, when a permanent enters the battlefield as a copy, it counts as "entering the battlefield" and triggers abilities like "Enters the Battlefield" (ETB), but if a permanent already on the battlefield becomes a copy, its ETB doesn't trigger because it never changed zones, notes Reddit users and Stack Exchange users. This applies to creatures, tokens, and other permanents, with the copy acting as a new object entering from another zone, activating its own abilities and those of things like Anointer Priest.Clones & Copy Effects Judge's Corner #69
When you copy something, does it ETB?
Yes. Creating is the new shorthand for putting a token onto the field. So if the copies creature has an ETB then that will trigger.Does copying trigger cast triggers?
A copy of a spell remembers all choices made when casting the original, but not whether it was cast. 707.10. To copy a spell, activated ability, or triggered ability means to put a copy of it onto the stack; a copy of a spell isn't cast and a copy of an activated ability isn't activated.What triggers ETB?
An ETB trigger (Enter the Battlefield trigger) in trading card games like Magic: The Gathering (MTG) refers to a special ability that activates automatically and immediately when a card (usually a creature or permanent) enters the game onto the battlefield, using keywords like "When," "Whenever," or "At" to start the effect, like drawing cards or dealing damage. These triggers create immediate value and are a core part of game strategy, happening just as the permanent arrives, allowing for powerful combos or reactions.Why are the planet lands not legendary?
Named lands often aren't legendary anymore because it was a design issue for constructed where the restriction was disliked. Maybe they will make a Planet rule similar to the Legend rule. Making the planet lands legendary is unnecessary from a balancing standpoint because they require so much investment and are slow.What is the rule 603.4 in Magic The Gathering?
603.4. A triggered ability may read “When/Whenever/At [trigger event], if [condition], [effect].” When the trigger event occurs, the ability checks whether the stated condition is true. The ability triggers only if it is; otherwise it does nothing.Why is Shadow Clone banned?
Shadow Clone Jutsu (Kage Bunshin no Jutsu) is not forbidden; it's a standard Academy technique, but the Multi Shadow Clone Jutsu (creating many clones) is forbidden because it drastically divides a shinobi's chakra and life force, making it extremely dangerous and potentially lethal for anyone without massive reserves like Naruto's. The standard version is safe for Jonin, but the mass version risks rapid chakra depletion and death, leading to its classification as a forbidden jutsu by the First Hokage.Can ETB effects be countered?
You cannot counter an enter the battlefield trigger with a traditional counter spell. If you want to do that it needs done on the casting of the spell.... You can use a card like [[Stifle]] to shut it down though.What is the best ETB effect in Magic The Gathering?
Craterhoof Behemoth + Moonshaker Cavalry. Craterhoof Behemoth has the best ETB effect in green because it almost always kills at least one player, and often the pod.Does flipping a morph trigger ETB?
It just changed states, from face-down to face-up. This is the same as when a double-faced card is transformed or when a permanent goes from being tapped to untapped. So morphing a creature doesn't trigger any ETB abilities like Impact Tremors or Pandemonium.Does copying a spell trigger Rhystic study?
No. When they cast a spell, your [[Rhystic Study]] trigger goes on the stack.What is the rule 701.27 A in Magic The Gathering?
701.27a To proliferate means to choose any number of permanents and/or players that have a counter, then give each one additional counter of each kind that permanent or player already has.Is 40 lands too much Commander?
40 lands in a Commander deck isn't inherently "too much," but it's on the higher end for typical decks; it's often perfect for high-mana curve decks, <<<>>landfall strategies, or decks with little card draw, but fewer lands (35-38) might be better if you have lots of ramp and draw spells. It depends heavily on your deck's strategy, average mana cost (CMC), and inclusion of mana rocks/ramp, with many players finding 36-40 a solid baseline for casual play.Can you have two legendary lands with the same name?
704.5j If two or more legendary permanents with the same name are controlled by the same player, that player chooses one of them, and the rest are put into their owners' graveyards. This is called the “legend rule.”Does transforming a card trigger ETB?
No, a standard transform in Magic: The Gathering doesn't trigger "enters the battlefield" (ETB) effects because the permanent stays in the same zone (the battlefield); it just changes characteristics, but some specific cards, like certain Planeswalkers or Battles, exile and then return transformed, which does trigger ETBs, or have text on the transformed side that triggers on entering the battlefield.Do creatures see their own ETB?
Yes, creatures can trigger their own ETBsThat said, the standard template for such abilities is "Whenever {cardname} or another [type] enters the battlefield", largely to remove exactly this sort of ambiguity.
Is mutate an ETB effect?
No, typically Mutate does not count as an Enter the Battlefield (ETB) trigger because the mutated creature spell fuses with a creature already on the battlefield instead of entering as a new permanent. However, if the mutate target becomes illegal (e.g., dies or leaves the battlefield) while the spell is on the stack, the mutating creature does resolve as a normal creature spell and will trigger ETB effects.Can you counter a copied spell?
Yes, you can counter a copy of a spell in Magic: The Gathering, because copies become their own separate spells on the stack, but it depends on how it was copied and the timing, as copies without targets (like from Storm) are harder to stop than targeted copies, and you can even counter the original to make the copying spell fizzle if it targets.How to avoid copycat?
Realize that Copycats Can't Keep UpWithout your originality, creativity, talent, spark, personality, and passion, any imitation will fall short and flat. If you dig deep into who you are, and follow your own path, no one is going to be able to take that from you.
Do counterspells stop cast triggers?
Yes, in Magic: The Gathering, typical counterspells do not stop "when you cast" triggers because the trigger goes onto the stack before the spell resolves, and countering the spell doesn't remove abilities already on the stack; you need specific effects like Stifle or Summary Dismissal to counter the triggered ability itself. Casting a spell puts it on the stack, triggering "when you cast" effects like Cascade or Storm; these triggers resolve before the spell, so even if countered, the trigger still happens.
← Previous question
Will NPCs leave Terraria?
Will NPCs leave Terraria?
Next question →
What is the future of the gaming industry?
What is the future of the gaming industry?