Is the Brotherhood good or bad in Fallout?

The Brotherhood of Steel (BoS) in Fallout isn't strictly good or bad; they are a morally grey, technologically-focused military order with noble aims (preserving knowledge, protecting humanity) often corrupted by fanaticism, xenophobia (towards synths, mutants, ghouls), and brutal methods, making them dangerous enforcers who prioritize control over freedom, depending on the game's chapter and leadership, like the benevolent Lyon's BoS versus the stricter, more zealous Maxson's BoS.
Takedown request View complete answer on reddit.com

Is the Brotherhood good in Fallout?

Fallout: Brotherhood of Steel is a divisive game; many fans hate it for straying from core RPG elements into generic hack-and-slash with poor writing, tonal issues (heavy metal in a bleak world), and annoying camera, calling it a "Burned Game". However, some reviewers and players found it a mildly entertaining, simple co-op dungeon crawler with decent action and controls, especially if viewed as a separate, basic Dark Alliance-style spin-off rather than a true Fallout RPG. Ultimately, its quality depends heavily on player expectations, but it's generally considered a poor entry in the franchise. 
Takedown request View complete answer on reddit.com

Is the Brotherhood evil in Fallout?

The Brotherhood of Steel (BoS) isn't strictly "evil," but rather a complex, morally gray organization whose actions are often seen as villainous due to their extreme, zealous, and sometimes ruthless methods for controlling dangerous technology, leading them to commit atrocities against synths, ghouls, and even innocent people in their pursuit of order and human preservation, though some factions (like Elder Lyons's in Fallout 3) prioritized helping people, making them antiheroes. They're often depicted as having a "for your own good" mentality that justifies oppression and violence, clashing with the needs of wastelanders. 
Takedown request View complete answer on reddit.com

Who is the real villain in Fallout 4?

The main villain in Fallout 4 is Shaun, also known as Father, the leader of the high-tech Institute and the adult son of the player character, the Sole Survivor, who seeks to replace humanity with synths and uses his parent as a pawn in his plan to take over the Commonwealth. Other antagonists include Conrad Kellogg, the mercenary who kidnaps Shaun, and the entire Institute, as well as other factions like the Minutemen, Brotherhood of Steel, and Railroad having morally grey or villainous elements depending on player choice. 
Takedown request View complete answer on reddit.com

Which faction should you side with in Fallout 4?

In Fallout 4, your choice of faction—Minutemen, Brotherhood of Steel, Railroad, or Institute—depends on your playstyle and moral compass, as each offers unique rewards (Power Armor, Ballistic Weave, Synths, or advanced tech) but also leads to conflict, forcing you to destroy others; the Minutemen are the moral "good guys" but weak, the BoS are militaristic tech-lovers, the Railroad frees Synths, and the Institute controls advanced tech but is morally questionable.
 
Takedown request View complete answer on reddit.com

5 Misconceptions About Fallout's Brotherhood of Steel

Who is the best ally in Fallout 4?

Once you maximize your bond, unique affinity perks unlock, and you may find them incredibly useful during your upcoming adventures.
  • Fallout 4: All Companions Ranked – Best Allies for the Wasteland.
  • Dogmeat.
  • Curie.
  • Paladin Danse.
  • Porter Gage (Nuka-World DLC)
  • Strong.
  • Preston Garvey.
  • Nick Valentine.
Takedown request View complete answer on g2a.com

Can I join all factions in Fallout 4?

Yes, you can join all four major factions in Fallout 4 (Minutemen, Brotherhood of Steel, Railroad, Institute) early on and do quests for them, but the main story forces you to choose one for the endgame, leading to the destruction of others, though the Minutemen can survive alongside the BoS and Railroad if you use them for the final push against the Institute. You'll hit "points of no return" where your choices make factions hostile, so saving before major quests like {!nav}Mass Fusion{/nav} allows you to explore all endings in one playthrough. 
Takedown request View complete answer on facebook.com

Is Preston Garvey suicidal?

Deep down, although not actively suicidal, Preston says he simply had given up hope for himself and the Minutemen and did not care if he lived or died; if he was going to meet his end, he would do it fighting as the last true believer in the Minutemen's justice.
Takedown request View complete answer on fallout.fandom.com

Can you befriend a deathclaw in Fallout 4?

Yes, you can tame Deathclaws in Fallout 4, primarily through the Wasteland Workshop DLC to capture them in cages for your settlements or, uniquely, through the Devil's Due quest to get a permanent, named companion by returning its egg. The DLC method involves building cages and using Beta Wave Emitters to pacify them for settlement defense or arena battles, while the quest offers a free-roaming friend. 
Takedown request View complete answer on reddit.com

Who nuked Shady Sands in Fallout?

In the Fallout TV series, Hank MacLean, a Vault-Tec executive and Overseer of Vault 33, ordered the nuclear destruction of Shady Sands in 2283 to eliminate the flourishing New California Republic (NCR) and prevent the surface world's true history from being revealed to the Vaults. He used his access and Vault-Tec connections, possibly involving the Enclave or pre-war technology, to deploy a nuclear weapon, erasing the NCR's capital and its burgeoning society. 
Takedown request View complete answer on reddit.com

What happens if I join Brotherhood in Fallout 4?

Joining the Brotherhood of Steel (BoS) in Fallout 4 grants you powerful gear (like T-60 Power Armor), access to unique vendors (Proctor Teagan), vertibird fast travel, and many quests, but it puts you on a collision course with the Railroad and Institute, eventually forcing you to eliminate them to win the game for the BoS. You can join early for perks, but you must eventually pick a side, locking you out of other faction questlines as you progress, though you can join all early on to get their benefits before the big choice. 
Takedown request View complete answer on reddit.com

What is the most evil Fallout faction?

Of every faction across every Fallout game, Ceasar's Legion utilizes some of the most inhumane methods in the franchise. Relying heavily on slavery, torture, and acts of violence to solve most of their problems, Ceasar's Legion is one faction you wouldn't want to come across in the wasteland.
Takedown request View complete answer on screenrant.com

Who should I blame for killing Nelson in Fallout 4?

Shifting the blame requires a Charisma check to succeed. If it fails, a Charisma check to apologize can be used to avoid Malcolm's hitsquad. If it succeeds, the player character can optionally implicate Marowski or Paul Pembroke as Nelson's killer.
Takedown request View complete answer on fallout.fandom.com

Can you join the Brotherhood if you join the Minutemen?

Yes, in Fallout 4, you can join the Minutemen and the Brotherhood of Steel (BoS) simultaneously and remain allies for most of the game, as the Minutemen are a flexible "yes" faction that supports you regardless of other choices, while the BoS will eventually conflict with the Railroad or Institute, not the Minutemen. You can progress in both storylines until critical moments where you're forced to pick a definitive path for the endgame, but you can keep both friendly until then, using the Minutemen as a backup to destroy the Institute for a good ending.
 
Takedown request View complete answer on reddit.com

How to get the peaceful ending in Fallout 4?

To get the most peaceful ending in Fallout 4, you must lead the Minutemen to destroy the Institute while keeping the Brotherhood of Steel (BoS) and Railroad friendly, which involves a specific sequence of completing quests for all factions, avoiding key "turning point" quests like Tactical Thinking (BoS) and Underground Undercover (Railroad), and using the Minutemen to build the teleporter for the finale, resulting in a Commonwealth where only the Institute is gone and the other major factions remain as potential allies. 
Takedown request View complete answer on reddit.com

Can you marry someone in Fallout 4?

No, you cannot get formally married to companions in the base game of Fallout 4, but you can develop deep romances, give them your wedding ring for roleplay, or use mods to add actual marriage ceremonies with perks and rewards. While you can commit to companions through the affinity system, the game treats them as lovers/partners, not spouses, with no official ceremony or in-game benefits beyond affection.
 
Takedown request View complete answer on reddit.com

Should I return the Deathclaw egg?

Whether you should return the Deathclaw egg in Fallout 4 depends on your playstyle: return it for a non-hostile Deathclaw, a free Deathclaw Gauntlet, and positive companion reactions (except Danse), or sell it to Wellingham for caps, with the "good" choice often being returning it for the gauntlet, though selling it prevents future Deathclaws. There's no single "right" answer, as returning it helps the creature but risks more Deathclaws, while selling it benefits you and potentially reduces threats, say players on Steam Community, Reddit r/fo4 and Facebook.
 
Takedown request View complete answer on reddit.com

What is the hardest enemy in Fallout 4?

The strongest enemy in Fallout 4 depends on playstyle and level, but top contenders include the Mythic Deathclaw (scales with player level, extremely aggressive) and the DLC's Enraged Fog Crawler (massive health/resistance, huge damage). For non-scaled foes, Liberty Prime is technically the biggest with 5 million HP (though a story element), while Ancient Behemoths, Mirelurk Queens, and high-level Assaultrons (like Gorgons) are also extremely challenging due to high health, damage, or unique abilities like stealth/lasers.
 
Takedown request View complete answer on youtube.com

Is piper a synth?

No, Piper Wright from Fallout 4 is not confirmed to be a synth; while some in-game speculation and theories exist (like a quest involving a fake Piper) and some players enjoy the mystery, lore generally indicates she's a human journalist, and there's no solid evidence she carries a synth component or has synth traits.
 
Takedown request View complete answer on reddit.com

Is Fallout 4 bigger than GTA 5?

SKYWORLD The map of Fallout 4 is much bigger, than most people realize. It's much SMALLER than people realize. The real landmarks are in a 40x40 mile square, but the game is more like 4x4 (it would be a 12 hour hike from 1 side to the other without cars) GTA5 is bigger.
Takedown request View complete answer on facebook.com

Is it possible to get 100% happiness in Fallout 4?

Meeting the needs of a settlement's population will allow a maximum of 80 happiness. Increasing happiness further requires stores that increase happiness, as well as pets. The maximum possible happiness is 100. Having beds outdoors will provide a happiness penalty.
Takedown request View complete answer on fallout.fandom.com

Who should I side with in Fallout 4?

Who you should side with in Fallout 4 depends on your playstyle and moral alignment, with the Minutemen (good for keeping everyone alive/generalist), Brotherhood of Steel (power armor/tech focus), Railroad (stealth/synth liberation), and Institute (advanced tech/morally gray) each offering different paths and rewards, but most players suggest saving often to explore options or focusing on Minutemen/Railroad for a "good" ending. 
Takedown request View complete answer on youtube.com

Can I join Railroad and Brotherhood?

Yes, you can join both the Railroad and the Brotherhood of Steel (BoS) in Fallout 4 initially and do quests for them, but eventually, you'll hit a point in the main story where you must choose a path that forces you to fight one of them, especially during the endgame when deciding to destroy the Institute. You can, however, use a specific, tricky strategy to finish the game with the Minutemen, keeping the BoS and Railroad alive by avoiding the Institute's final quests and instead taking the Minutemen route to destroy the Institute, which avoids conflict with the other two. 
Takedown request View complete answer on reddit.com

Can you betray all factions in Fallout 4?

You can destroy everyone except the Minutemen. But assuming you go Railroad way, they take out institute and Brotherhood. After institute is gone just go shoot them - save x688 before the end story snd take him to the hq for good measure as this makes you instant enemies with Railroad.
Takedown request View complete answer on reddit.com

Previous question
Is GreedFall 60 fps on PS5?
Next question
Who kills Sebastian in Thule?